Derivative work, Similar Work..

Chat about anything not covered in these forums, but keep it civil!

Post » Sun Nov 04, 2012 4:44 pm

This is an interresting topic.Where do fan made games fit in?.Are they also violating certain copyright laws if it's a fan made game?.How strict are these laws exactly?.There's 1000's off mario , rockman etc clones out there and i don't see them being deleted from certain websites.

I also played a few world off warcraft fanmade games and videos and they don't get deleted or sued.Nor do certain people which has popular tv programs as thier signatures.I think one should read the legal info about a game or whatever first before making a fan made banner ,game etc.
B
22
S
3
G
6
Posts: 1,356
Reputation: 7,141

Post » Sun Nov 04, 2012 5:20 pm

[QUOTE=DravenX]Where do fan made games fit in?. Are they also violating certain copyright laws if it's a fan made game?.[/QUOTE]
Yes they are.

[QUOTE=DravenX]How strict are these laws exactly?.There's 1000's off mario , rockman etc clones out there and i don't see them being deleted from certain websites.[/QUOTE]
Just that you don't see it happen doesn't mean it never happens.

It's never a clear cut case. Most fan made games are pretty bad, and for the IP holders most of them don't enter into the IP holders signal to noise ratio. The two most common causes for a fanmade game to be C&D'd are a) if they are actively making money off the project, or b) the quality of the game is sufficient enough as to detract from sales of proper releases.

Nintendo has shot down quite a few fan projects. The most memorable for me being the Ocarina of Time de-make, where a guy was recreating Ocarina of Time using A Link to the Past assets.

However, copyright (like trademarks and patents) is something that the holders must actively enforce themselves. Simply put, the reason you see so many games that do not get taken down is because there are so many games that people make. It's not feasible to C&D each and every one.

In some cases, though, an IP holder can actually encourage fanmade material, as it generates good-will. AFAIK Lucas Arts have been pretty openminded about fanmade material (though Disney is quite the opposite. I wonder which way this issue will tilt with Disney at the reins).

Hasbro is also pretty openminded about fanmade material for MLP:FiM, for instance, but not without limits. They haven't done anything against Fighting is Magic, but the fanmade Magic: The Gathering MLP set was C&D not too long ago.

Edit: What is this, the fifth or tenth time this discussion has come up? inkBot2012-11-04 22:29:00
B
73
S
20
G
10
Posts: 524
Reputation: 9,896

Post » Sun Nov 04, 2012 5:39 pm

I think it is a good thing that those laws are in place.

But like every law, it can get to some nitpicking issues ^^

Let's see how it goes.
B
40
S
11
G
4
Posts: 665
Reputation: 8,403

Post » Sun Nov 04, 2012 10:53 pm

[QUOTE=inkBot]

Nintendo has shot down quite a few fan projects. The most memorable for me being the Ocarina of Time de-make, where a guy was recreating Ocarina of Time using A Link to the Past assets.[/QUOTE]

Haven't heard of that, is that a recent thing? Doesn't sound like Nintendo, when I was young I spent many years in the fan game communities and Nintendo didn't seem to care about any of them.
B
134
S
65
G
16
Posts: 1,766
Reputation: 19,190

Post » Mon Nov 05, 2012 1:33 am

@alspal:

The key thing there is that Nintendo didn't seem to care. Just because you didn't see it doesn't mean it didn't happen, and as a rule Nintendo have traditionally been pretty strict about this type of thing.

I'm a staff member and forum moderator at a very popular game development site (GameDev.Net), and 5 or 6 years ago now after requesting we take down recruiting posts for a few individual projects -- who themselves received C&D notices -- Nintendo actually made a blanket request that we do our best effort to disallow any fan project using Nintendo's properties.


Just commenting on something above as well, obviously if you re-use an asset (model, sprite, whatever) from an existing game -- even if you modify it -- you're violating copyright. A lot of people don't realise however that if you create a new asset for yourself completely from scratch but based upon something from an existing game you're still creating a derivative work.
B
24
S
5
G
2
Posts: 104
Reputation: 3,136

Post » Mon Nov 05, 2012 8:38 am

I know Tetris sued a similar game and won
B
40
S
11
G
4
Posts: 665
Reputation: 8,403

Previous

Return to Open Topic

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Slenderman8557 and 3 guests