You should have, but I know from other posts on the forum that Notch is one of the ones with the most wonkiness and often requires a manual award.
I'm also missing a couple awards, notably a Religious Updater from a week ago. Out of curiosity, when you go to your list of badges
, does the "Badges Earnt" number match a manual count of your badges below?
In my case, I show 49 badges earned, but a manual count shows I have only been awarded 47.