The Do's & Do Not's of Game Design

Discuss game development design and post your game ideas

Post » Tue Dec 16, 2014 11:41 pm

Interesting post, enjoyed reading it
B
6
Posts: 2
Reputation: 208

Post » Sat Dec 20, 2014 8:08 pm

Great post, and thanks for sharing!
B
8
S
2
G
1
Posts: 47
Reputation: 653

Post » Sat Feb 14, 2015 2:48 am

Do not read game design articles.
B
45
S
11
G
4
Posts: 517
Reputation: 7,398

Post » Wed Feb 18, 2015 3:30 am

xoros wrote:Do not read game design articles.


Why not? :)
B
20
S
8
G
4
Posts: 195
Reputation: 3,555

Post » Wed Feb 18, 2015 8:53 am

IMHO, the stuff in this articles does not translate to reality.

Is it possible to write a wonderful piece of music after reading a musical theory book or beats production tutorial? No - if a person does not have talent, but if you have a talent you'll be doing it just right without any books and articles.

The only rule of thumb is keep practicing. Carefully observing/studying features from other good games by playing them also helps a lot.
B
45
S
11
G
4
Posts: 517
Reputation: 7,398

Post » Wed Feb 18, 2015 11:38 am

Pehaps the points in this article don't translate to reality, but this article don't necessarily represent game design articles at large. But it does have a good amount of good points, it all depends on what game you make. This is not the be-all end-all of game design, it's one article, written by a journalist and not a designer.

Writing music and developing a game are two very different things, believe me I do both. One is about recognizing pitch and having a trained ear, muscle memory and dexterity. game design, not so much. Game design is a lot of theory: psychology, behaviorism, most importantly logic. All do translate well into articles and other written media.

Post-mortems are some of the most interesting articles I've ever read and there's tons of great information in them. Game design articles can contain great amounts of knowledge and tricks that you can learn of instead of running into the wall yourself and learning the hard way. There was a double fine "dev plays" episode featuring John Romero, it was amazingly interesting and I learned a great deal from it, you should def. take a look. I strongly disagree that you should not seek out prior knowledge, which is part of reading articles and consuming other kinds of similar media (video interviews with devs for example).

That said, no one expect to be able to perfectly master a skill just by reading about it. Articles are a good tool, a very good tool I might add and will most likely aid you as a developer more than hurt you. It's not a substitute for practice and no one suggested as such. I believe every developer should read as much as they can but be smart about what information is useful for their game. Information is never not useful, eventually. So absorb it all for future reference. :)
B
20
S
8
G
4
Posts: 195
Reputation: 3,555

Post » Wed Feb 18, 2015 2:10 pm

Well, yes, it will definitely not harm, but you will not start producing better games after reading game design articles. Only practicing as much as you can: participating in game jams, hackatons, sketching your ideas on paper, writing game design docs, finding a game dev job, drawing game characters etc. - that will make you a better game designer.

I'm also a musician - I can tell you music and games have a lot in common. Playing music is all about talent, translating your personality into the groove and melody and looots of practicing.

Again, IMHO.
B
45
S
11
G
4
Posts: 517
Reputation: 7,398

Post » Wed Feb 18, 2015 3:33 pm

I thoroughly disagree. As I've stated above, it will help but it's not a substitute for practice and skill. If an article talk about level design and what benefits certain tricks will have (for example: loop-backs, intuitive color schemes, flow etc.) then anyone who don't know those subtleties of level design will have to learn it the hard way instead of thinking "yeah that's right never thought of that" after reading an article on the subject.

It might not work for you personally, but I strongly disagree with the notion to discourage people from reading articles on the subject.
B
20
S
8
G
4
Posts: 195
Reputation: 3,555

Post » Wed Mar 04, 2015 10:50 am

Funny article. Although it strikes me more of an outlining of tropes sometimes. Tropes aren't always bad, sometimes they serve a good use.

Of course, definitely good tips for immersion!
B
9
S
2
G
1
Posts: 48
Reputation: 710

Post » Sun Mar 15, 2015 9:15 pm

xoros wrote:Is it possible to write a wonderful piece of music after reading a musical theory book or beats production tutorial? No - if a person does not have talent, but if you have a talent you'll be doing it just right without any books and articles.


As a guy who have played the guitar for 15 years, and fiddling around with various music production programs, I must say that I agree. I used to create better and more original music before I started learning the theory. Now I am all tied up in scales and so on, instead of creating music from the heart.

Though, I am not sure if the case is the same with game design. Game mechanics is something that has to be right, or else the game will feel clunky and unprofessional. Reading articles can prevent this from happening..
B
10
S
2
G
1
Posts: 16
Reputation: 642

PreviousNext

Return to Game Development, Design & Ideas

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests